Every year, our department has a “holiday” party. We usually go to a bowling alley for lunch and bowling (fun fun fun), and then a gift exchange follows. It’s the pollyanna type where everyone brings a wrapped gift valued between $20 and $25, people draw numbers and then pick or steal gifts in numerical order.
The problem of course is that we have a diverse group of people, and so you would need to find something that “works” for both the hypothetical close-to-retirement male and a fresh-out-of-college female. So, you usually end up with 3 classes of gifts. (1) Alcohol (2) Gift cards (3) random, useless junk that someone brings as a prank. For example, $20 worth of those pine-tree shaped car air fresheners, or a set of novelty Santa Claus undergarments (size small). Every now and then you get a 4th group consisting of something really creative and thoughtful, but that’s rare.
Now, if the people who bring useless gag gifts go home with the same category, I’d say okay, haha, so be it. But that’s not how it ends up of course. (1) I don’t drink, so a bottle of wine or scotch or a case of beer would be useless to receive. (2) Why should I bring a $25 gift card to Target just to walk home with a $25 gift card to Best Buy? I’ll just keep the $25 and spend it how I please. (3) I don’t want to get burned by some prankster, especially if I am not going to be a prankster myself.
Ergo, I’ve pretty much decided that I will not participate in the gift exchange, and haven’t done so for quite a few years now. When questioned, I’ll usually say I didn’t have time to get anything to avoid dealing with a ressponse of “you’re no fun.” True, I’m not. What else is new?
I just don’t get the rationale behind these pollyanna gift exchanges. Now, in the interest of disclosure, I’ve been a part of many of them, and have even organized a few. I’ve gotten stuck with some less-than-desireable things at such events, and I’ve been guilty of regifting some junk as well. I realize they can be entertaining, and may solve some problems that surface because of the volume of people involved (it’s much easier than a Secret Santa system for instance).
But why do we even have to do a gift exchange in the office? The mentality seems to be “it’s the holidays, so we must get presents to be ‘in the spirit of the season.’” Cuz gifts are what the holidays are all about, ya know? I believe that pollyanna gift exchanges trivialize the whole notion of gift giving.
Has anyone noticed how we’ve gone from GIVING gifts to EXCHANGING gifts? We seem to want some sort of parity between what is given and what is received on the gift front. It’s as if we no longer give gifts to people out of love and/or respect. No, we exchange gifts because it’s the thing-to-do. To make matters worse we hide behind cloaks of anonyminity when we do it.
Phooey.
If I’m going to give someone a gift for whatever reason, I want to pick out something that I think that person will enjoy or find useful. Not just a gift for gift’s sake. The whole meaning is lost when one has to buy something — anything — for a complete stranger. It’s not a gift then.
So, rather than participate in the pollyanna, I will simply sit it out again this year. And I’m not hiding behind a lame excuse this year either. And if that makes me no fun, then I will wear that badge with pride.