There’s a new Geico commercial out there where what I assume is supposed to be the president or other big mugwump at Geico is talking to the gecko about how the company is apparently trusted, and they need to promote that Geico is the company people trust. Then, the president suggests they engage in one of those “trust building ” activities wherein the president will fall backward off his desk into the waiting arms of the gecko, fully trusting the little bugger will catch him.
This brings back a flurry of memories of “team building” exercises like that. I’ve lost count of how many activities growing up featured such things where you were expected to just engage in some dangerous activity trusting that the rest of your team will be there to protect you. The Boy Scouts were especially fond of this, and I remember it also being featured as part of my Confirmation retreat. (How hurling ourself off the edge of a platform into the arms of a bunch of fellow 7th graders was supposed to prepare us to be sealed and strengthened by the outpouring of the Holy Spirit is anyone’s guess.)
Now, I am a klutz. I am perfectly capable of tripping and falling accidentally, so there’s really no reason for me to purposely throw myself off the edge of a platform to see if I get banged up. Add to that my general fear of heights, and suffice it to say I avoided participating in any such activities as much as possible, even when it was considered “mandatory.” Then came the nagging — what’s the matter, don’t you trust us? Aren’t you a team player? You have to do this, we’ll have much more respect for you if you at least tried it. Whatever. To my credit, I DID participate in a trust walk on a retreat once — where people were partnered up and one was blindfolded and the other led him around the grounds avoiding obstacles and such. But nothing involving heights.
Maybe I just take the words of the Gospel quite seriously. When Satan took Jesus tp the parapet of the temple and suggested He hurl Himself down and see if God will send angels to protect Him lest he dash His foot against a stone, Jesus replied that it’s also written that you should not put God to the test. I see enough of a parallel here; no testing God for me!
On further reflection, I don’t know how people think these activities actually build trust. I was paired up with a compete stranger on the trust walk, and don’t think I even remember his name right now. Sure, I “trusted” him when he was leading me around, but he also “trusted” me when it was my turn. On my confirmation retreat, or on those scout events, I could have “trusted” that the other kids would catch me, just as each of them “trusted’” the rest of us would catch them as they took a turn. And afterward, I still wouldn’t have loaned a dime to any of them with any expectation that I might get repaid.
These activities don’t build trust. They really are only examples of the threat of mutually assured distruction. If I’m a guide on a trust walk and he hits a low tree branch, I know when I’m the blind one I’m going to end up falling into a muddy ditch. And if I’m the one catching the kid falling from the platform, if I don’t do my best to keep him from hitting his head, I know when it’s my turn, I’m eating dirt.
Suppose instead of a blind trust walk, the retreatmasters instead decided that we would have to tell our partner some private, potentially embarrassing detail about our lives and trust him to keep it secret. Would you? Probably only if you could get some equallyembarrassing secret out of him so that if he blabs, you can blab too. Otherwise, forget it!
Trust is built and earned over time, not instantly there because someone says it ought to be. I’m blessed with many close friends who I would trust implictly with just about anything – be the keys to my car or my bank PIN or a personal/emotional issue. That trust developed over time, and as our friendships developed. Not simply because I hurled my body at the group of them and they caught me.