Last week we gave “the test” for Confirmation in PREP/CCD. As expected, my kids’ results could at best be called lackluster, though I blame that as much on the test as their own ability. The wording of some of the questions is tough, and the subtle nuances between Wisdom, Understanding, Knowledge, and Counsel were not very well distinguished, in my opinion. But, I didn’t create the test, and others may have taught the subject matter differently.
At any rate, one of the “essays” was to describe the 15 hours of service they did, and what corporal and spiritual works of mercy they see in their service. I was amused by some of the responses, and irritated by others. I think I need to propose to the Coordinator of Religious Ed. that the service requirements be beefed up a bit.
Some examples of “service” presented:
- I helped my grandparents decorate for Christmas
- I babysat my brother/sister/cousin/neighbor for free
- I played in a charity soccer tournament
- I did some extra chores around the house, like taking out the trash
- I helped my little brother/sister with his homework
Now, I grant you that there were also some good examples on there (like helping in a food bank, and volunteering for the church festival, and visiting the residents of a nursing home). But I’m amazed that scenarios like the above would ‘count’ for service. Helping out family is not, in my mind, community service, but rather a matter of being responsible. Likewise, I’m not sure how playing in a soccer tournament counts as “community service.” I suppose the tournament probably raised money for a cause, and if the kids didn’t play there’d be no money for the cause, but I still think it’s a stretch.
Back when I was a kid (and I had to walk barefoot to CCD for 8 miles in 3 feet of snow carrying my little sister on my back) we had to do 40 hours of service. Further, there were different categories, and we had to do at least 5 hours in each category. I believe they were as follows: Church, Church Festival, Poor/Homeless, Senior Citizens/Sick, and Other. There might have been a category for children/education or something like that too. It’s been a while.
The goal was to ensure that we did a considerable amount of service in a variety of areas. Each activity we did required us to fill out a form documenting the service and what we learned from doing it. The kids today just had to have a single sheet on which they wrote their service hours and had a parent sign off. Back in the day, we needed signature not only of a parent, but also the contact info and signature of someone at the organization.
I’m seriously recommending talking with the pastor and the CRE to see if things can’t be beefed up a bit. Because I really don’t think helping Grandma put ornaments on her Christmas tree or taking out the trash when it’s your brother’s turn is what Jesus meant by “what you did for the least of these, you did for me.”
